Size 8 vs size 12 on the Air Max 1: 4% over the floor against 59%
A size 9 is the cheapest size on seven of the twenty pairs. A 12 is the priciest on ten of them.
On the Air Max 1, a size 8 typically costs the least: just 4% over the cheapest size of the same pair. A size 12 typically costs the most, at 59% over. I looked at twenty of the most-listed men's Air Max 1 pairs in my nightly checks, each with prices in at least eight of the nine sizes from 8 to 12.
Here's what the premium means. For every pair, I take its cheapest size as the floor and compare every other size to it. A premium of 4% means a size 8 usually sells for only a little more than the cheapest size, and often it is the cheapest size. A premium of 59% means a 12 usually costs well over the floor of the same shoe. Each figure is the median across the pairs, so single pairs can land far from it.
Size by size
- Size 8: the lowest typical premium at 4%, and the cheapest size on six pairs.
- Size 9: 10% over the floor, and the cheapest size more often than any other, on seven pairs.
- Sizes 8.5 and 9.5: these half sizes typically cost more than the whole size right after them, 13% for an 8.5 and 24% for a 9.5.
- Size 11.5: 48% over, and the priciest size on five pairs.
- Size 12: 59% over, the priciest size on ten pairs and never the cheapest.
Sizes 11, 11.5 and 12 are not the cheapest size on any of the twenty pairs.
Examples
Three pairs from the study show how far apart sizes of the same shoe can be.
Air Max 1 “Have A Nike Day” is cheapest in a size 8 at $159 and priciest in a size 11 at $687. That size 11 is the outlier: the next priciest listed size, an 11.5, is $313.
Air Max 1 “Mica Green” starts at $133 in a size 8.5, $17 under its $150 retail, and a size 8 is $135, also under retail. Its priciest size is an 11 at $316.
Air Max 1 “Dark Teal Green” is cheapest in a size 9 at $166 and priciest in a 12 at $308.
If you wear an 8 or a 9, you're in the cheap part of the size run, and I'd start with the size 8 Air Max 1 prices. In a 12, expect to pay more than the price at the top of a pair's page, and check every Air Max 1 in your size.
Prices from our Nov 17, 2026 check: the lowest price of a new pair with the original box, by US size. The model page always shows the latest prices.